Martha’s Vineyard vs Nantucket: The Honest Comparison You Need!
I dyllic islands, small town vibes, bicycle rides and gorgeous shorelines – what more could you want? Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket, just off the coast of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, are both wonderful summer destinations.
But at only 30 miles apart from each other, what’s the differences between them? And which is right for you?
In fact although close in proximity, these destinations are actually quite different! Nantucket is smaller, more conservative and has fantastic public beaches. While Martha’s Vineyard is liberal, busier, and has more options when it comes to restaurants, shops, and nightlife.
Luckily we know and love both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard. So below we’ll be doing a deep dive into what each has to offer.
We compare the vibe, beaches, activities, and more. All so you can make the right decision on which one to pick!
- A Quick Overview
- Which Has Better Vibes & Things To Do?
- How Do The Activities & Attractions Compare?
- Where You Should Stay According To Your Budget
- Which Is Better?
A Quick Overview Of Martha’s Vineyard vs Nantucket
Nantucket, meaning “The Faraway Land” in the language of the Wampanoag tribe, is located 30 miles from the coast of Cape Cod. It has actually been previously named “the best island in the world” by National Geographic.
There’s gorgeous beaches on the island, no doubt, but also authentic lighthouses, surf, and boutique shops.
The island itself isn’t huge – 14 miles long and 3.5 miles wide – and you can actually get the ferry ride over and then cycle around without the need for cars at all. In fact, we think that’s the best way to see Nantucket!
It’s made up of two quaint towns and is easy to get around with no need for taxis or even a car. In contrast, Martha’s Vineyard is more than double the landmass of Nantucket, and made up of six towns. To enjoy it all you’ll need your own car or to use public transport.
Back to Nantucket! This charming island is perfect for relaxing, or enjoying the fresh seafood that you can buy along the shoreline.
There’s also plenty of public beaches in Nantucket. That’s not the case in Martha’s Vineyard where many beaches are private and off-limits.
That’s one big difference between Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard. At Nantucket there’s often more opportunities to enjoy the natural scenery. Be that on Nantucket’s many public beaches or immersing yourself in nature thanks to over 40% of Nantucket being protected conservation land.
Martha’s Vineyard was originally called Noepe, meaning “land between the streams”, and was also named by the Wampanoag tribe. It’s just seven miles from Cape Cod – compared to Nantucket’s 30 miles – so you’ll get a shorter ferry journey over. That’s a bonus for those not flying in.
Tribal origin isn’t all that these two islands share; in 1602 Martha’s Vineyard got its name from Bartholomew Gosnold – the same man who first sighted and settled in Nantucket in that very same year!
He named the island after his daughter Martha, and due to the viney undergrowth he found on the coast. So don’t be fooled by the name: there are no actual vineyards on the island!
This island is popular with the rich and famous, and has quite a liberal and artsy feel to it. Nantucket, on the other hand, feels a little more conservative.
Due to its size and the fact it has more settlements, there’s also more to do on Martha’s Vineyard. There’s a livelier restaurant and nightlife scene too. More so than Nantucket, as we’ll show you below.
That makes Martha’s Vineyard probably the better choice if you’re looking for a mix of exploring towns, nature, trying out different restaurants, and taking part in a variety of activities.
Which Has Better Vibes & Things To Do?
Both destinations are clearly rich in history, and have fascinating backstories dating back centuries.
They are both also very invested in their tourism industry. That means you will have plenty of excursion possibilities and accommodation choices despite the size of both islands.
Nantucket has actually prioritised tourism since the 1800s due to a need to bring in money after a decline in the traditional whaling activities on the island.
Martha’s Vineyard is also a very popular place, so much so that there’s an increase in population of about 10 fold each summer!
But what else makes these islands unique and different from each other?
It’s quiet in Nantucket (quieter than Martha’s Vineyard), and serene. Staying here will almost take you back in time to when it was a 19th century whaling town.
The island is made up of brown shingle buildings and white sandy dunes. There’s a truly historic and authentic charm that is exuded throughout. There are plenty of great eating options and upscale restaurants too, as well as boutique shops.
This is certainly an upmarket place, and there’s a real New England charm and preppy chic feel to it.
On the culture side, there are activities for everyone ranging from scenic walks along Sconset Bluff Walk, or boating tours from the harbor.
And of course, you must not forget to visit Nantucket’s gem: its whaling museum in the heart of downtown! After all, this was the whaling capital of the world back in the mid-1700s to late 1830s!
The island is also home to over 800 meticulously restored pre-Civil war homes. That’s more than anywhere else in the United States! So this is definitely a place that history buffs will enjoy.
We recommend experiencing the island’s rich history first-hand. So not only should you wander the streets finding those pre-Civil war homes, but you absolutely must visit Nantucket’s three iconic lighthouses – Brant Point Lighthouse, Sankaty Head Light, and Great Point Lighthouse. All are a throwback to 18th century Nantucket.
Finally, although smaller and less busy than Martha’s Vineyard, Nantucket is also in some ways more open and accessible. Not only can you travel around on foot or bike (and it’s less hilly than Martha’s Vineyard), Nantucket’s more-than-30 beaches are all open to the public. That’s a huge bonus!
In essence, this is a laid-back and quiet island where you can see history come alive with your own eyes through the gorgeous restored architecture and museums.
Nantucket is also an island perfect for exploring nature, hiking, kayaking, biking quaint roads, and enjoying the beaches unhindered.
On the other hand, a lot of – but not all of – the beaches on high-end Martha’s Vineyard’s are private. So you need a permit to access them.
Regardless of that, this island is still heavenly for those who love the outdoors. With hills and cliffs, 124.6 miles of tidal shoreline and a third of its landscape protected, a lot of this island’s character comes from its natural beauty. So there’s plenty of nature to enjoy, even if some of the beaches are off-limits.
While we’ve established there are no vineyards, Martha’s Vineyard does have some top-tier microbreweries for you to enjoy. There’s also 50 local farms that are indicative of the island’s local commitment to sustainable agriculture.
In fact Martha’s Vineyard is big on their food and harvest scene, and you can partake in walking tours and foodie tours in Spring and Autumn to get involved in celebrating the island’s produce. That’s one of the reasons – along with the many great restaurants on the island – that we think Martha’s Vineyard may suit foodies more than Nantucket.
Another thing we like about Martha’s Vineyard is the authentic independent vibe that remains there. This island hasn’t been tainted by inland chain stores, restaurants or hotels. Instead it fosters a supportive local artisan and entrepreneurial community where everything is one-of-a-kind.
Equally, the arts and culture scene here is fantastic all year round. So you can fill your evenings with classy trips to galleries, live music events, theatre trips and enjoy entertainment after soaking in the breathtaking views that day.
That’s one of the big things that sets Martha’s Vineyard apart from Nantucket. The art and music scene at Martha’s Vineyard really is a winner.
How Do The Activities & Attractions Compare?
Although tiny, there are plenty of things to visit and do in these small but mighty islands.
We’ll briefly outline some of our favourite places to go to unwind and get the most out of your holiday. As you’ll see, what you can do on each island also tells you a lot about its character and whether it will be the right vacation choice for you or not.
Windswept beaches aren’t hard to find here, but neither is calming open expanses of land if that’s more your thing. If so, check out the conservation areas!
Dionis Beach is one of our favorite places on Nantucket – it’s beautiful, peaceful, and situated on a harbor. With about 300 feet of loose sand before you get to the beach itself, it makes for a romantic day out. It usually isn’t too crowded either.
Similarly, there’s also Jetties Beach, one of Nantucket’s most popular beaches, located just on the edge of town on the north shore.
It’s a huge beach which gets its name from the jetty – as you might have guessed! It comes fully equipped with a beachfront restaurant, café, and tourist shop for those all-important mementos!
At this point, it might be worth mentioning that the film Jaws was actually filmed throughout Martha’s Vineyard! That’s because producers considered Long Island to be too busy, whereas Martha’s Vineyard provided that ‘eerily empty’ atmosphere!
So, just in case you want to retrace 27 year-old Steven Spielberg’s footsteps, we’ll highlight some of the places that featured in the film.
In a nutshell: the opening scene was set in the Martha’s Vineyard harbor town of Vineyard Haven; the night-time bonfire on the dunes was at South Beach in Katama; and the infamous first shark attack was just off Cow Beach at Edgartown. And there’s your whistle-stop tour, and three destinations to add to your Martha’s Vineyard bucket list!
You get bonus points if you strike up a conversation with some of the older locals. They usually have the best stories to tell as many were casted as extras in the movie itself!
Where You Should Stay According To Your Budget
Shoestring: The Jared Coffin House, one of Nantucket’s most well-known hotels, captures the spirit of this former fishing town with its attractive lodgings.
This hotel is a significant Nantucket landmark, and is located in an old mansion where you can unwind in lovely guest rooms and welcoming public areas. The air-conditioned rooms provide magnificent views of Nantucket town and are adorned with artefacts and soothing classic colours.
Experience the island’s bustling downtown just a few steps away, and thanks to the location you’ll be right beside many stores, restaurants and activities. See photos and prices by visiting this link.
Budget: With its calm residential environment, green gardens and laid-back atmosphere, Life House Nantucket – located in a historic inn from the 19th century – is quality but at an affordable price.
You will get a delicious complimentary breakfast every day in the lounge here, or why not gather in the gardens or on the veranda and enjoy sipping your tea and coffee.
You’ll be close to all the action too, including beaches and restaurants, so this hotel is perfect for getting the most out of your Nantucket stay. See photos and more at this link.
Luxury: The Nantucket Hotel & Resort is one of Nantucket’s most illustrious hotels (see photo below) and one of the few hotels on the island open all year. It’s a destination distinguished by its combination of luxury and laid-back island vibe.
There’s a variety of luxury suites, rooms, and cottages at the resort, some with views of the ocean and an outdoor hot tub.
The hotel also features a fitness club, spa, children’s activities, an on-site restaurant with fire pits, and two seasonally heated outdoor private pools. Beaches, shops, restaurants, boutique stores, and art galleries are all just a few minutes walk away. See more photos and prices by visiting this link.
Shoestring: Edgartown Commons could be the ideal accommodation for your Martha’s Vineyard trip as it offers reasonable, comfy lodgings at a fantastic price.
This self-catering residence features an outdoor pool, a playground for kids, and a picnic area with barbecue grills. The building is near restaurants and shops on Main Street in Edgartown, and close to the harbor’s waterfront too, so you’ll be close to all the action. See photos and prices by visiting this link.
Budget: The Harbor View Hotel in the picture-perfect community of Edgartown, bordered by miles of stunning beaches and coastline. It’s a wonderful budget option.
This premium resort (see photo below) offers visitors the ultimate Martha’s Vineyard getaway, complemented by fantastic on-site restaurants and spectacular views of the harbor. And all without breaking the bank.
Only a few steps separate this famous hotel from shops, art galleries, beaches, and sunset cruises. So you’ll have everything right on your doorstep. See more photos and prices by visiting this link.
Luxury: Hob Knob Luxury Boutique Hotel & Spa is a luxury hotel that has welcomed guests for nearly a century.
Picture the ideal escape on Martha’s Vineyard, with excellent personalized service, spa services, and relaxation in a calm, sophisticated atmosphere. That’s what you get here.
The Hob Knob is ideally situated in the heart of Edgartown too, so you’re just steps away from the city’s museums, delectable seafood at many great restaurants, and a wide range of outdoor activities. See photos and prices by visiting this link.
Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket: Which Is Better?
The obvious difference between these islands is size, and while size isn’t everything, it can make a difference depending on how adventurous and varied you want your holiday to be.
Nantucket is made up of just two quaint towns, compared to Martha’s Vineyard six, and subsequently there’s more going on in the latter.
However, both definitely offer an escape from urban city life. Just in slightly different ways.
Martha’s Vineyard is often visited by celebrities and politicians, and has a preppy boho/ casual and laid back style. Everyone goes everywhere in bathing suits, flip flops and shorts. It also has a more affluent African American community, and this is reflected in its more liberal and artsy community.
While you won’t get bored in either, due to its sheer size Martha’s Vineyard does have more options, be that restaurants, shops, and nightlife. However that does mean you’ll need to look at using buses or a car to get around, whereas in Nantucket you can just use a bike if you wish.
On the flipside, getting to Martha’s Vineyard is usually slightly easier, as typically it sees ferries and flights coming in more frequently.
Meanwhile in Nantucket, things are slightly more upscale. It’s smaller, more familiar, and more conservative. While you can obviously and definitely dress however you want, the general go-to look is preppy chic – so think New England preppy getaway.
Nantucket has the advantage of its beaches being open to the public, but as a note this island tends to grow to a summer population of about 50,000, so accommodation books up fast!
In the end both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard make for amazing holidays, and ultimately it’s completely down to your own preferences. Whichever you choose, have fun!
Nantucket Vs. Martha’s Vineyard: 7 Key Differences To Know
Pristine beaches, maritime history, and beautiful scenery are all part of an island escape. In New England, two of the most picturesque island destinations await: Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard, both located off the southern coast of Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Both can only be reached by boat or air, and on both islands, peak season begins on Memorial Day weekend and ends on Labor Day weekend. A few shoals and about 30 miles separate the two islands, which were both formed during the Ice Age. While each destination inspires fierce loyalty, there are key differences between them to keep in mind when deciding which to visit.
1. Location, Size, And Population
About 30 miles off the coast of Cape Cod, Nantucket beckons to visitors to experience its coastal beauty. Just 14 miles long, the crescent-shaped island is easy to explore by bike, and the island shuttle buses have bike racks. Nantucket is home to just one town and two zip codes, and many of the restaurants and shops are located downtown in Nantucket proper.
Martha’s Vineyard is located closer to the mainland, only 7 miles offshore across Vineyard Sound. With about 125 miles of coastline, the island comes in at close to 96 square miles, about twice the size of Nantucket, making a car more of a necessity. The town’s population soars from 17,000 to close to 200,000 in summer — about twice the number of seasonal visitors to Nantucket.
Insider Tip: Up island, down island, on island, and off island are all part of the local vernacular used to describe someone’s whereabouts or give directions.
2. Transportation Options
You can travel to both of these award-winning destinations by air or sea. The frequency of transport, however, is quite different.
Ferries to Martha’s Vineyard leave from several locations along Cape Cod as well as from New Bedford, Massachusetts, and Kingston, Rhode Island. (By taking the ferry from Rhode Island, you can avoid the Cape Cod traffic on a busy weekend.) The ride only takes about 35 minutes. In addition, there is a SeaStreak ferry from New York City that takes 5 hours. Flights to Martha’s Vineyard depart from big city hubs as far south as Washington, D.C.
Nantucket’s car ferry is booked months in advance, so planning is essential if you want to bring a vehicle. The Steamship Authority (car ferry) and Hy-Line Cruises (passenger ferry) are both based in Hyannis, Massachusetts. A SeaStreak ferry departs from New Bedford. The ferry ride can take anywhere from 1 hour to 3 hours, depending on the boat you choose. Flights to the Nantucket Memorial Airport run from Boston, New York, and Hyannis.
If you plan to visit both islands, you’ll be interested to know that there is an interisland boat that runs during peak season and takes 1 hour.
3. Geography And Architecture
Nantucket, Martha’s Vineyard, and Cape Cod all border a triangular area of the sea referred to as the Sound. However, the geography and architecture of Martha’s Vineyard are quite different from those of Nantucket.
Martha’s Vineyard features many high cliffs and rolling hills. It’s also home to six towns, all with their own personality and rich history: Tisbury, which offers an excellent natural harbor; Oak Bluffs, with its multicolored gingerbread Victorians; Edgartown, which includes the infamous island of Chappaquiddick; Chilmark, with its rolling hills and green space; West Tisbury; and Gay Head, now called Aquinnah, which boasts dramatic, colorful cliffs leading down to the sea.
Nantucket is so flat that most everything can be seen from the roads. The highest point on the island, Sankaty Head, home to one of Nantucket’s three lighthouses, is located 111 feet above sea level. You won’t find any box stores or traffic lights, and the town of Nantucket is the only one on the island. At the eastern end of the island is the small hamlet of Siasconset, with its rose-covered former fishing cottages on white shell paths. The Nantucket Historical Association’s strict building and restoration codes allow only a few paint colors on the island, and most of the buildings are clad in weathered gray shingles. Stepping off the ferry onto the cobblestone streets of Nantucket is like stepping back in time.
The main attractions on both Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket are the beaches. Martha’s Vineyard has 124 miles of coast, while Nantucket has only 80. The beaches on both islands run the gamut from small spots with calm waters, perfect for children and families, to challenging waters with pounding surf. Lifeguards are only present on some of the beaches, so make sure to check before heading out, especially if there are little ones in your party.
All of the beaches on Nantucket are open to the public. On Martha’s Vineyard, there are public beaches in Edgartown and Oak Bluffs, but many of the others require a parking permit, so be sure to ask about access when booking your vacation.
Nantucket has more of a buttoned-up vibe than the Vineyard. Nantucket Reds™, cotton canvas pants or shorts that fade to a dusty rose, are de rigueur for men and are often worn with a collared button-down shirt and blue blazer in the evening. Like the beach pass bumper stickers, which are a status symbol on cars, faded pants are stylish — they indicate that you’re an island regular! Women will be quite comfortable in their Lilly Pulitzers with cardigans draped over their shoulders. The social scene on Nantucket attracts captains of industry and the country-club set.
On Martha’s Vineyard, you’ll rarely feel underdressed in flip-flops and shorts. Don’t let the island’s name fool you — the only vineyard you’ll find on the island is Vineyard Vines, a preppy line of clothing and accessories that is very popular both on and off island. Effortless style rules here: Think understated, simple, and chic. The island is popular with politicians and Hollywood types.
There’s no denying that these islands are pricey. Some of the most expensive real estate in the country can be found on both, and the shops, restaurants, and hotels are mostly high end. The sheer size of Martha’s Vineyard, however, allows for more variety, so it will be easier to find budget-friendly accommodations and restaurants there.
There’s something hauntingly beautiful about fog. Both islands get plenty of it, but on Martha’s Vineyard, more often than not, the fog departs by noon. If you are a lover of misty mornings and harbors clad in gray, get up island and enjoy the sailboats parked in Menemsha Harbor as the sun rises. All is covered in a mysterious blanket that provides great photo opportunities.
Nantucket is nicknamed “the Gray Lady” for a reason. Sometimes, the fog sticks around for an entire weekend. While I would never dispute the picturesque beauty of this shadowy covering, be sure to plan alternatives to the beach. One of the many museums would be a great place to spend a few hours with the family. Keep in mind that, while one part of the island (frequently Cisco) may be covered, it is often bright and sunny down island or on another beach.
You can’t go wrong with a visit to either Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard. On both, you’ll find a vibrant arts and culture scene that’s active throughout the year, as well as great restaurants and chefs serving up fresh seafood. Both destinations offer family-friendly hospitality that encourages multigenerational travel. Either would make an ideal celebration location for an anniversary, birthday, or retirement party.
Keep in mind the things that set these two former whaling capitals apart, and you’ll be guaranteed a memorable stay, no matter which island you choose.
Alison Abbott is an award-winning travel writer and photographer with a focus on sustainable shades of green living. When not searching out the best of artisans, growers, and makers who make a destination unique, you can find her working as editor of the blog she founded, Green With Renvy.
As a Baby Boomer who loves adventure, she has swum with pink dolphins in the Amazon, crossed paths with grizzlies in Alaska, and ventured to Chernobyl in Ukraine. Her travels have taken her around the globe to off-the-beaten-path destinations, but India holds a special place in her heart. Her passion for responsible travel has her singing the praises of keeping it local whether at home or abroad. Alison is a regular contributor to many online publications and is a Local Expert with AFAR Media.
Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard: How to Choose
In New England, travelers often choose sides for summer vacations: Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket. For me, it was always the Vineyard. Every summer, my family would rent a home in outermost Aquinnah, where wild beaches and towering red-orange clay cliffs provide refuge from crowded ferry towns to the east. But then Nantucket came along: I met my fiancé on the sands of Surfside Beach and celebrate anniversaries dockside at Cru. Since then, travels have been split—summer bike rides on Chappy in the Vineyard, sunsets in Nantucket’s Madaket.
For the few who frequent both islands, that’s often how it goes. “Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard are a family,” says Mark Snider, owner of The Nantucket Hotel & Resort and Winnetu Oceanside Resort on Martha’s Vineyard. “The islands are different and they can be loved for what makes them special but ultimately, you love them equally.”
After all, since the whaling era that was their prime, Massachusetts’ favorite islands have shared a symbiotic relationship. Here, what makes them who they are.
Travelers to the Vineyard may be dismayed to find that there are no vineyards—but a casual, ever-relaxed environment (that certainly lends itself to sipping wine seaside) makes the 26-by-9 mile island (a 30- to 45-minute ferry ride from Cape Cod) a true escape. “You can go almost anywhere on the island in shorts, a tee shirt, and flip flops,” says Rob Blood, CEO of Lark Hotels, which has two properties on Nantucket and three on Martha’s Vineyard.
Start in Oak Bluffs, a port town decorated with colorful, Victorian gingerbread homes. “I love the porch culture. With so many Victorian cottages and great summer homes, there is a laid back afternoon rocking chair, cocktail culture that oozes summer,” says Blood.
Foodies don’t have to switch islands either, as Martha’s Vineyard has its own emerging scene. Head to lower Kennebec Avenue in Oak Bluffs, says Blood. “There’s one of the best whiskey-bourbon bars that I’ve ever been to, 20byNine; an amazing chef-driven bistro called Red Cat Kitchen; and an island-to-table fine dining restaurant called Down Island, all just steps from one another.”
Bike the nine miles from Katama to Oak Bluffs. “This morning ritual is one of my happy moments,” says Snider. Six of the miles are along the ocean.
Take the bike ferry in Aquinnah to the old fishing village of Menemsha for takeout at the Galley. “The Vineyard’s great experiment is to visit the different parts of it so you have a sense of its history, diversity, and beauty,” says Snider.
Listen to live music at the Ritz in Oak Bluffs, says Blood: “Thursday nights there are particularly amazing.”
Nantucket’s ubiquitous gray-shingled houses.
While travelers will find the Vineyard to be diverse and colorful, the Quaker roots of Nantucket forbid that, says Snider. “It was monolithically singular and gray.” Today, those historic gray-shingled homes are what make Nantucket authentic. “The island is very mindful of its culture,” says Snider.